MY PROJECT

 EcoEng Newsletter 2, July 2000
 

Demonstration Environmental Sanitation Project at Monteverde, Costa Rica

By EcoEng Correspondent Stewart Dallas, Costa Rica

Stewart Dallas is currently a postgraduate student from Murdoch University in Perth, Western Australia, with a degree in civil engineering. There he worked with the Institute for Environmental Science focusing on appropriate, environmental technologies in the areas of water treatment, sanitation and renewable energies. He was Technical manager of the group's Environmental Technology Centre (ETC): a two hectare site on campus which researches and demonstrates a range of environmental technologies in a permaculture-designed landscape. He defected from the realms of civil engineering after some 8 years much to the horror of his bank account to pursue more grassroots-orientated, environmentally friendly endeavours. In this article he describes his current project in Costa Rica.

Info Monteverde Institute: http://www.mvinstitute.org

The Situation in Monteverde

Monteverde, in northwest Costa Rica, has experienced massive growth in the last two decades due to eco-tourism. Since 1982 visitor numbers have risen from some 300 individuals to over 55,000 in 1999, resident population from 1500 to approximately 9,000 and the number of hotel beds from 25 to over 1700.

Development has proceeded in an ad-hoc fashion and local planning for the region has been virtually non-existent. Needless to say the associated environmental impact has been considerable. (‘Monteverde’ is generally used to describe the three communities of Monteverde, Cerro Plano and Santa Elena which are all adjacent to cloudforest vegetation on the Cordillera de Tilaran at an altitude of 1200-1600m).

Costa Rica has whole-heartedly embraced eco-tourism as a source of much-needed foreign exchange and until recently it was the nation’s number one industry in terms of financial turnover. While the country is famous for its enlightened approach to conservation and its sheer biological diversity, the impacts from unlimited ecotourism, population growth and a lack of any national master plan are being felt. In particular it is widely recognised that the pollution of water and water bodies, in hand with diminishing fresh water supplies, is now a real threat to the livelihood of all species, including Homo sapiens! (Of note: In Latin America 98% of all sewage is discharged completely untreated and this has resulted in high rates of disease and gross pollution, mainly as a result it has been argued, due to adherence to the principle of the water-based ‘flush and discharge’ technologies.

Wastewater Treatment Today

Septic tank systems remain the prevailing wastewater disposal paradigm in Costa Rica. Based on my observations and discussions of their ‘performance’ here in the Monteverde region they are: of poor design, generally poorly installed, overloaded, located too close to water courses and infrequently pumped out. Greywater from laundries and bathrooms is often piped directly out of the house onto the ground with no treatment and rapidly finds its way into the nearest streamline due to the steep terrain. On the other hand, the available potable water supplies in this region are high quality freshwater springs and stream sources eminating from high in the watershed. Water quality sampling downstream of population centres however reveals the rapid deterioration in stream water quality both in terms of macroinveterbrate/biological as well as chemical indicators.

The two seasonal variations however both exacerbate and mask the true extent of the problem: in the dry season (Dec-April) it is common to see and smell greywater and septic overflow in the roadside drains and freshwater supplies are stretched; in the wet season (May-Nov) torrential daily downpours flush away and dilute the effluents and water supplies are abundant.

My Project

My current project at the Monteverde Institute’s Community Art Centre is to construct and demonstrate two types of environmental technologies: a composting toilet and a reedbed system to biologically treat the Centre’s greywater. The main philosophy behind this demonstration project is provide a low-cost, non-polluting, sanitation alternative to the typical flush-and-discharge systems, which conserves and reuses water, and is open to the general public.

Reedbed System

The reedbed is now functioning after approximately 8 weeks’ work involving volunteers, local school students, workbees, donations of materials and was all carried out by hand. Sizing of the reedbed was an iterative process based on available space, estimated future greywater volumes and impact of the wet season rains (there is also the potential for a small café to be run from the Centre in the future and a removable clear plastic roof system to divert rainfall from the reedbed is presently being trialed).

The reedbed is approximately 7.2m long, 1.8m wide and 0.6m deep and is a plastic-lined, subsurface-flow system based upon a design by Marshall. An internal plastic baffle wall extends the flow path to approximately 10m before water discharges to a shallow (0.2m) open pond (2.0m dia.). To reduce costs, gravel for the reedbed was largely replaced with cut up plastic (PET) drinking water bottles (I used a local non-recyclable brand) to provide an inert media and structural support for the plant roots. This plastic bottle layer was then topped with 15cm of crushed rock and the reedbed planted up.

Due to the region’s steep topography, wetlands - and hence native wetland plants - are non-existent, however several non-native reed species were located in a few isolated areas and were identified. The reedbed was planted with "Job’s Tears/Lagrima’s de San Pedro” (Coix lacryma-jobi), a member of the Tripsaceae family as the species considered to be the most suitable and yet non-invasive. Recent research however suggests that mixed resident vegetation may in fact prove to be more effective at nutrient stripping than monoculture systems such as this and some experimentation with this will be attempted.

After passing through the reedbed, the treated greywater flows into a shallow pond containing fish and some floating aquatic plants, before overflowing into a soakage basin planted with banana, two types of bamboo, sugarcane, taro and lemongrass.

At present the reedbed only receives greywater from two sinks within the Centre however a third sink as well as urine direct from the urine-diverting composting toilet will soon be connected. The main challenges to date have been: wet-season rainfall in terms of construction interference and excessive reedbed throughput due to the additional water volumes; and mosquito larvae populations in any standing water during construction (goldfish have been introduced to the pond for mosquito control).

Composting Toilet

The design for the composting toilet is for a sealed tank arrangement (modified HDPE water tank) utilising slotted drainage pipe and an electric fan to maintain a constant aerobic environment, and innoculated with active compost and worms to assist in the aeration and breaking down process. Worm farms of various sizes are widely seen in the area particularly where organic farming techniques are being practiced such as for vegetable and coffee production.

While this arrangement does not simulate a typical domestic situation it will hopefully demonstrate an ‘in-principal’ environmentally-friendly local sanitation alternative (the Community Arts Centre will experience usage factors typical of a day-only public facility such as high urine and low fecal solids input). It will also provide experience with local plant species, soil and topography factors, climate, availability of materials, local social and cultural considerations before a perhaps more ambitious project for the area is undertaken.

 
© 2000, International Ecological Engineering Society, Wolhusen, Switzerland